Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Welcome to Tugf. We hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
Doctor-Assisted Suicide - The Right to Die?; For, Against, On Fence? Tell, tell.
Topic Started: Apr 15 2009, 12:55 PM (67 Views)
Star
Member Avatar
Supreme Protagonist
Quote:
 
In 1992, Sue Rodriguez forced the right-to-die debate into the spotlight in Canada.

In a video statement played to members of Parliament, the Victoria woman, diagnosed with Lou Gehrig's disease in 1991, asked legislators to change the law banning assisted suicide.

"If I cannot give consent to my own death, whose body is this? Who owns my life?" she said.

The Supreme Court of Canada ultimately ruled against Rodriguez, but her struggle galvanized the public. Rodriguez committed suicide in 1994 with the help of an anonymous doctor.

In Canada, as in most countries, assisted suicide is illegal. But there seems to be a growing movement toward changing the law in many parts of the world.
What is the difference between assisted suicide and euthanasia?

Assisted suicide occurs when a person — typically someone suffering from an incurable illness or chronic intense pain — intentionally kills himself with the help of another individual.

For example, a doctor may prescribe drugs with the understanding that the patient plans to use them to overdose fatally. Or a doctor may insert an intravenous needle into the arm of a patient, who then pushes a switch to trigger a fatal injection.

Assisted suicide differs from euthanasia, in which someone other than the patient ends the patient's life as painlessly as possible.

Euthanasia may be active, such as when a doctor gives a lethal injection to a patient.

It can also be passive, in cases where a physician doesn't resuscitate a patient whose heart has stopped. Or it can happen when a doctor removes life-support equipment.
When did assisted suicide become a legal issue?

Philosophers have contemplated the concept of "a good death" since ancient times. However, individual choice over dying only surfaced in intense public debate in the 1970s.

Until then, anyone found guilty of attempted suicide in Canada — and in many other countries — could face jail time. The federal government decriminalized attempted suicide in 1972.

The legal right to turn down medical treatment emerged at the same time, as technological advances in medicine allowed doctors to keep patients alive longer.

A series of court cases in the 1970s won a mentally competent person's right to refuse medical intervention — a view now widely accepted.

The debate over patient autonomy now centres on issues of active euthanasia and assisted suicide, as patients who live in chronic intense pain or with a degenerative or terminal illness such as multiple sclerosis, AIDS or Alzheimer's disease fight for the right to die.
Why is it an issue?

People who want assisted suicide to be legalized believe that individuals should be able to control the time and circumstances of their own death. Some argue that actively causing one's own demise is no different from refusing life-saving treatment.

Opponents fear that vulnerable individuals may be coerced into assisted suicide to ease the financial burden of caring for them. They also worry that assisted suicide could ease pressure to provide better palliative care and find new cures and therapies.

Some religious opponents argue that God, not humans, should decide the time for death. And many medical professionals maintain it is never morally permissible for doctors to help kill a patient.


I believe that people should have the right to die.
If someone is at the point where they are in so much pain, they don't recognize family, they are so confused and frightened they don't know what's going on, they can't breathe, or they are brain dead, I think they should have the option of having their pain taken away, and relief for the rest of their family.

I think this because my mom watched my great-grandmother suffer in a hospital (she had ovarian cancer) and she just got worse and worse and the doctors weren't even giving her pain medication, so she was suffering so much...My great-grandmother was so scared the whole time, wasn't enjoying the life she did have, and was in so much pain she almost couldn't tell if anyone was there. She was going to die anyway, and she wasn't dying in a dignified and comfortable way...My mom begged the doctors to do something to help her grandma, and finally they increased her morphine level so high that she fell asleep and didn't wake up. Her last words were "thank you." While my mother was obviously sad about the loss of her grandmother, she was at least relieved that she wasn't suffering anymore and that she was able to go to a better place. I don't remember this because I was only three months old when she died...

So I believe that people should have the rights to their own body and reserve the right to die if they are in so much pain they can't take it and the docs can't save them. People should be able to leave the world the way they wish, instead of being forced to live in pain. Why should someone hate their last moments on the planet, they should be surrounded by family and just be able to go to sleep if they want to...death should be as comfortable as possible, it's hard on everybody involved.

Well, that was my opinion. I do hope I haven't offended anyone, and I am interested to hear what you guys think.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Mathaldar Hawthur
Member Avatar
My life would be nothing, without you here to listen...
I have to agree with you. I think that if a person is in that much pain without there being any cure, then yea they should have the right to ask for it. Then again what if the person isn't in a well state of mind? should they still be given the rights to choose if they die or not? technically its still suicide, so what if your doctor is religious? Will they be willing to commit to that? Don't forget its not only the person whos dieing feelings, how would you feel knowing that your helping someone commit suicide, even if it is to relieve them of their pain.

When someone i trying to commit suicide everyones like "you have so much to live for, think of how you'll hurt those around you". sure you might no longer be in pain, but you gotta realize how suicide effects people. I have had people commit suicide in my family...........trust me its not something thats easy to deal with...theres never really a time when you can even comprehend why they would ever leave you like that...how they could think them leaving would be "better". because it isn't..it really isn't....

i'm sorry but i can't continue at the moment. I'll add more later maybe, but thats my opinion on it so far :)

sorry for any offences in my rambling.....
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Star
Member Avatar
Supreme Protagonist
Jesse, what you're saying makes perfect sense. I actually kind of regret that I made this topic, because it's such a difficult subject to talk about. I sincerely apologize, but appreciate that you shared your opinion with me. I do agree with what you said, but I'm wondering now if maybe this is an inappropriate topic...?

I'm not sure I was clear...I meant only in terminal patients, that were going to die anyway. But still, you're right, suicide is suicide.

You raised some really important points in your post and I'll validate them when I get back from school lol. :)

I just wanted to say thank you, and that I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings.



Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · Debates & Serious Discussions · Next Topic »
Add Reply